Backlash Over "Game of Thrones" Showrunners' New Show Begins
It's been less than 24 hours since HBO announced a new series from the showrunners of Game of Thrones, and it's already inspired anger from all corners of the internet. Surprisingly, they didn't even need to cast Ed Sheeran.
HBO gave the green light to Confederate, a new series from D.B. Weiss and David Benioff about an alternate history in which slavery never ended because the southern states successfully seceded from the Union. This leads to a Third American Civil War and a cross section of characters fighting across the Mason-Dixon Demilitarized Zone.
Considering the current ease with which Americans discuss issues of slavery, racism and civil rights, this will probably fly right under the radar. Oh, there's already a backlash? Right, that makes sense.
Taking to Twitter, many have already commented on the show, particularly the potentially dangerous imagery and subject matter of a series like this from writers already known for their, let's say, less than delicate handling of sex, violence and race. Needless to say, the buzz is not positive, and it's drawing very few defenders.
if hbo is really going to make a godawful show about confederate slaves in an alt-2017 let me save you the trouble here is what happens pic.twitter.com/u5ycC5t2IS
— DOCFUTURE (@topherflorence) July 19, 2017
I don't care if it is done tastefully as possible.The VERY premise is DISGUSTING.Especially now.Who are you pandering to?
— Unfazed (@unfazed_post) July 19, 2017
The fandom for the new #HBO show #Confederate is gonna be Tragic. Can you imagine how much harmful imagery they're gonna produce? pic.twitter.com/P9xbxfQQtv
— Zora Neale Hustlin' (@MarsinCharge) July 19, 2017
Confidential to HBO: Nobody on here thinks #Confederate is a good idea.
— David M. Perry (@Lollardfish) July 19, 2017
These guys seem to stir a controversy without even trying.
This recent one comes hot on the heels of Weiss and Benioff irritating most of Westeros with an appearance from pop-singer Ed Sheeran on the season premiere of Thrones. Sheeran, who played a sweet singing soldier, quit Twitter for several days following his appearance. Though unconfirmed, many speculate that he left over criticism his cameo. After all, he has criticized Twitter in the past. "I go on it and there's nothing but people saying mean things," Sheeran said. "Twitter's a platform for that."
James Podeswa, the Sheeran episode's director, said of Sheeran: "He is one of the nicest guys in the world, and he really is one of the guys. He’s lovely, he’s a team player, he wants to do a good job, he takes direction, he’s very open. He’s a big fan of the show and he was really excited to be a part of it. I think his lovely voice was used to great effect and he just has a really nice presence. He blends into the world of the show in a nice way where if you didn’t have all these associations with him and his musical career, nobody would even blink about his presence on the show."
The Internet, by and large, however, had one word for this and the new show:
Share Pin
mayne83
I was expecting the Alt Right to be pissed off for not depicting the Confederacy as an Aryan Utopia. But I guess this makes as much sense.
anxietydecending
Pretty sure Sliders already did this so NBD
Gentleman Quagsire
Assumedly Lynyrd Skynyrd is the exact same in this universe.
A Can of Moths
I’m glad somebody else reference Man In The High Castle. It highlights the ridiculous double standards we enforce as a society. High Castle not only brought about imagery of a fascist america, but they also bluntly reference the eradication of the Jewish people on an routine basis. The shows antagonists are (obviously) highly anti-Semitic and theres even a scene where the government gasses a Jewish family in a Police station like its business as usual. But despite this show’s premise, nobody batted an eye. There was no controversy, no backlash, no outcry from the SJW community. Do you know what critics said about High Castle? They praised it: its fresh, unique, thought provoking, and powerful… and I completely agree with them.
So what we’re seeing here is basically the SJW community picking and choosing the nationalities / cultures they wish to defend. Its ok when its the Jews being imprisoned and exterminated in a show, but if god forbid it’s the African American community. Despite the fact that this is still a reality in the war-torn regions of Africa where extremist groups like Boku Haram still exist.
AliC202
This is an ad masquerading as a news post. Manufactured controversy aka Ghostbusters Reboot. And look at everyone who fell for it.
Benus
This isn't going to glorify or jsutify slavery, just as (most) war films don't glorify or justify war. They may glorify the positive virtues of people involved in what is considered a shitty situation, but a war is generally not portrayed in a positive light in any film.
tman105
im gonna wait and see on this one. If handled correctly it could be a good show. if handled poorly it could be a shitshow, but im not ready to completely throw my hat one way or the other.
My best behaviour
With how the left has basically gone batshit insane ever since
RussiaDonald won the elections, this just wasn't good timingChewybunny
Really good vide on the subject
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yhNbgoeEUwM
OnlineSoup
wait till the fucking show comes out before getting outraged goddamnit! whats even the point?!