It's been a long-running joke how the meaning behind symbols and messages will often be lost in translation when they make their way between the East and West. Ariana Grande gets a Japanese tattoo that reads “charcoal grill,” Asian merch advertises “Boston, Msaeachubaets” and people from both cultures have a good laugh.

Of course, errors in translation can also get people into deep trouble, as the world is seeing now with K-pop idol Chaeyoung of TWICE, who in the span of a week has worn a QAnon shirt and another shirt with a swastika on it.

These are two huge oopsies for the idol, particularly as TWICE are making the rounds on American television in promotion of their single "Set Me Free."

Some fans noted that both incidents could be reasonably explained — if one is perhaps fortunate enough to not know about QAnon, a shirt with the letter Q and the words "We Go All" does not read as particularly offensive, and Chaeyoung's sporting of it could be a simple error on the part of her stylist.

In the case of the "swastika" shirt, the shirt is less a "pro-Nazi" shirt than it is a shirt with a picture of Sid Vicious of the Sex Pistols on it, and Vicious's shirt has a swastika on it.

Still, the fact that both of these incidents happened in such close proximity to each other was a wildly unfortunate coincidence, and some weren't charitable with their interpretations of how these controversies came about as they generated backlash online in recent days.

Some accused her of promoting antisemitism and others called for her to be fired.

The latter suggestion seems unlikely to happen. Both Chaeyoung and her agency, JYP Entertainment, posted "apologies" for the swastika shirt, though neither has commented on the Q shirt incident as of the time of writing.


Share Pin


Comments 5 total

Chewybunny

Really?
"Swastika on her tshirt"
No. She has Sid Vicious on her shirt, who famously wore the swastika shirt here:

I'm increasingly convinced that the constantly ever-offended can only contextualize things within their own lifetimes, and are utterly incapable of dealing with any form of history; artistic, social, national, etc, outside of their tiny little lives.

1

SSmotzer

It's called shock marketing.
Like when fashion stores make a hoodie with mistral show lips, or sweaters with Holocaust style Stars of David on them.

Build up free publicity by doing something offensive, then release a statement apologizing. Or try and trigger a small community, and have them start a boycott campaign and people will tune in out of spite of the boycott.

2

RemChi

It could also be an intense language barrier. There's these kinds of shirts everywhere in Asia because companies see hot buzz words and just put them on shirts, or popular images or just popular people.

7

NeatCrown

Eris brought up a pretty good point a couple of days ago that I'd like to repeat; The Swastika could be similar to how Westerners don't get the same shock from seeing Imperial Japan's Rising Sun flag. The severity of the symbol is just not as ingrained.

1

Chewybunny

Or it could be that she likes a tshirt with Sid Vicious on it.

0
pinterest