(Twitter / @BenShapiro, @joemayall)

Yesterday on his Daily Wire program The Ben Shapiro Show, Ben Shapiro said he invented a mathematical formula to calculate the legitimacy of a government or any other kind of institution. After going viral over the last 24 hours, the video has since led many online to mock him and exploit an irresistible meme template.

In the clip, Shapiro described his math by saying the numerator of the formula refers to positive things the government does (such as "S," representing "social solidarity," and "R," representing the government's responsiveness). The denominator then refers to "things the government can do to undermine its own authority," including "R," which represents the government's "regulatory strictness."

Shapiro did not say how he would assign numbers to each of these variables, nor did he account for differences within a population (a government may, for example, be stricter or more responsive toward a certain class of people). Shapiro also didn't mention considering other factors that may contribute to government legitimacy, nor did he define exactly what he meant by "legitimacy."

As the video continues, Shapiro used his formula to argue that Western governments should get smaller, because, according to his take, "consent matters more than control" for government legitimacy.

Perhaps unsurprisingly, clips and screenshots of the moment were critiqued or criticized by some internet users heading into today as it spread on platforms like Twitter.

Additionally, people have already begun memeing the screencap of Shapiro gazing at his formula, creating various Photoshop edits that replaced the original image.

Others simply mocked Shapiro for making the formula or joked about using it for their own purposes.

Shapiro is undoubtedly one of the most-memed pundits in America, and the memes have notoriously expanded to include his sister too. Part of this may be due to him being very online — unlike some other political commentators, as Shapiro began his career blogging and posting and not standing in front of a TV camera. Another part of it may be due to the speed at which he talks and the virality of certain moments (like this one and his recent Glass Onion review) that people can't help but talk about.


Share Pin


Comments 3 total

winton overwat

I mean, the top level concept of "Proportionality to Consent of the Governed, Inverse Proportionality to Authoritarianism" doesn't feel egregiously wrong but it's impossible to even begin assigning values to this variables.

Also, as part of the consent of the Governed he lists the Ability to Leave the Territory…so is Comrade Shapiro here saying that if the People are too poor to afford moving out that means the Government loses Legitimacy?

2

Briham

This is just peak Shapiro. A "formula" for something unquantifiable to allow his opinion masquerade as legitimate and objective fact. It's just like a PragerU graph: looks nice but doesn't actual convey real information.

7

Venusgate

I think the real irony is, "government legitimacy" is not even a tangible concept.

It's like a nerd proving, via math, that the bully is emotionally inferior. Right before getting swirlied.

1
pinterest