Healthcare.gov

Submission 11,334

Part of a series on Obamacare. [View Related Entries]

About

Healthcare.gov^[1] is the online marketplace where U.S. citizens can enroll in a range of healthcare insurance plans in accordance with the U.S. Healthcare Reform. Since its official launch in October 2013, the website has drawn criticisms for frequent downtimes as a result of high traffic volume and critical bugs in the software.

History

One of the provisions in the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act^[2] of 2010 called for an online health insurance exchange with a marketplace where individuals could buy their own health insurance that would launch on October 1st, 2013. In April 2013, a finalized version of the health care application^[4] went live online, in preparation for those planning to make a purchase in October. By September, news sites like the International Business Times^[3] posted articles on how to navigate the site and what documents shoppers would need to have handy in order to make a purchase. Healthcare.gov (shown below) launched on October 1st, 2013, despite the government shutdown that also began the same day.

Controversies

Launch Failure

Its first day online, Healthcare.gov crashed (shown below) after receiving more than 1 million visitors^[7] in less than 24 hours, with the marketplaces for residents of Maryland^[5] and California^[6], among others, becoming completely unusable.

That same day, Redditors from /r/WebDev^[11] began picking apart the code, finding a number of spelling errors and other issues. By the following afternoon, Healthcare.gov attracted 6.1 million unique visitors.^[8] Site issues continued to persist, and on October 5th, the Washington Post^[9] interviewed application management expert Jyoti Bansal, who theorized that the site's problems were actually glitches in untested code and not solely due to traffic problems. Flaws in the design were acknowledged on the 6th by Joanne Peters^[10], a spokeswoman from the Department of Health and Human Services, who also reported the site had seen more than 9 million customers, but actual purchases were in the low thousands. On October 8th, Slate^[12] broke down a number of the site's problems, noting an error message containing a phone number to call for help had been hidden in an HTML comment tag in the site's source code, making it so it would not display anywhere on the page.

Obama's Response

On October 21st, 2013, President Barack Obama held a press conference (shown below) to discuss the Healthcare.gov glitches and downtime, during which he said there is no excuse for the flaws in the system and that no plan would not sell out and will be available throughout the enrollment period.^[13] Later that week, the President asserted that the site would work more smoothly by November 30th.^[14]

Congressional Hearing

On October 24th, a hearing was held in Congress in which representatives from the contracted companies that built the site, CGI Federal and Quality Software Systems Inc., gave testimony as to what would have caused the issues.^[15] Both representatives claimed that their half of the software worked, blaming the federal government for the problems.^[16] Slate^[17] suggested that the representatives did not know that some bugs were unacceptable and were too optimistic about a program that did not fully work.

Marilyn Tavenner's Apology

On October 29th, chief of Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services Marilyn Tavenner (shown below) issued a formal apology for the website as part of the Congressional hearing. She was the first member of the Obama administration to testify at the hearing, stating that the site did not live up to the government's expectations. She also noted that more than 700,000 people have successfully submitted coverage applications, but did not specify how many of those people actually were enrolled in benefit coverage.^[18] The same day, many news sites including CNBC^[19] and Bloomberg^[20] reported that hundreds of thousands of current health insurance plans were being cancelled for not covering minimum policies under the Affordable Care Act, including more than 300,000 in Florida and 280,000 in California.

Highlights

Obamacare Girl

As malfunctions and glitches continued through the latter half of October, an image of a smiling woman prominently displayed on the homepage soon became the scapegoat of the launch failure, inspiring a slew of late-night talk show satires as well as online mockeries.

On October 21st, The Onion highlighted the woman in an article titled "People In Healthcare.gov Stock Photos Now Visibly Panicking,"^[24] featuring a photoshopped image of the woman with a frightened facial expression (shown below). In the following days, the mysterious woman became dubbed the "Mona Lisa of Health Care" in the political blogosphere and news media, as well as drawing attention from online discussion forums, before it was replaced with another image on October 27th.

On November 13th, the woman in the photograph appeared in an exclusive interview with ABC News Good Morning America^[25] to discuss the ordeals of her newfound fame as the face of Healthcare.gov. The woman, who only wishes to be identified by her first name "Adriana," also asserted that she has become a victim of cyberbullying as a result of the unwanted association with the website.

"The saga of the photo started innocuously enough. Seeking free family photographs, Adriana emailed a contact at the Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services, the agency responsible for the Affordable Care Act's rollout, about having photos of her and her family taken in exchange for allowing the photos to be used to market the new health care law. She was never paid."

Traffic

On October 1st, Healthcare.gov saw 2.5 million unique visitors, but that number steadily dropped, hitting 500,000 on October 10th and continuing to trend downward.^[21] Despite the traffic drop, the percentage of visitors that actually completed an application increased from 0.3% to 5.7% between October 1st and October 24th (shown below). Though Healthcare.gov's Quantcast^[22] statistics are hidden, the site has an Alexa^[23] score of 238 in the United States.